Zurawski v. Texas
Held that the language in state abortion laws allowing abortions when the life of the mother is threatened is adequate to protect the health of the patient and constitutional. Plaintiffs seek a declaration and injunctive relief from the court clarifying that the bans do not prevent physicians from providing abortions under statutory exceptions for “medical emergencies” when patients face risks to their life or health. They also request a ruling that any enforcement of the bans by state officials contrary to the court’s declaration would be beyond the scope of the officials’ authority. Additionally, they claim that, to the extent the bans could be read to prohibit abortions in the case of medical emergencies, the bans violate the state constitution’s 1) due course of law clause as to both the rights of patients to abortion when their life or health is at risk and the rights of physicians to perform such abortions (Art. I, § 19) and 2) guarantees of equal rights and privileges and equality based on sex (Art. I, §§ 3 and 3a). A trial court temporarily blocked enforcement of the bans against pregnant people with emergent medical conditions. It separately found that the enforcement provisions of S.B. 8 are unconstitutional. The defendants appealed to the Texas Supreme Court and the court heard oral arguments on November 28, 2023.
Related Commentary
Access to Reproductive Health Care for Minors Is a Political Flash Point
Courts in some states have ruled that laws requiring parental consent for abortion are unconstitutional, while Idaho forbids nearly all medical care for children without parental consent.
An Eventful Summer for State Constitutional Abortion Rights Litigation
State supreme courts addressed abortion rights head on, even as the U.S. Supreme Court punted on similar questions.
Center For Reproductive Rights Litigation Director Discusses the High Stakes of Abortion Litigation
State Court Report spoke with counsel for the plaintiffs challenging Texas’s strict abortion ban — which the state supreme court just ruled was constitutional.
Texas Supreme Court to Determine Scope of ‘Medical Emergency’ Exceptions to Abortion Bans
The plaintiffs include 20 women who were denied abortion care and two doctors who say Texas’s abortion bans prevent them from meeting their ethical obligations.